PAKENHAM OFFICER STAR NEWS
Home » Mental health system questioned

Mental health system questioned

By CAM LUCADOU-WELLS

MENTAL Health Minister Martin Foley has said that careful consideration will be given to a Coroner’s findings into a man who killed a work colleague after being released from Casey Hospital’s mental health ward days earlier.
The findings into the 52-year-old Narre Warren victim’s death were released on 6 July, prompting his widow to pronounce the “broken” mental health system had let her family down.
The victim’s wife told the News that she had pushed for the inquest because she didn’t want another family to go through the same torment.
“My husband was in the wrong place at the wrong time with the wrong person,” she said.
“It could happen to anyone unless we see change.
“Our system is broken, and it needs to be fixed.”
In his findings, State Coroner John Olle recommended that acute-care mental health patients should have access to therapeutic recovery units and specialist forensic psychiatrists prior to their release.
Mr Foley said on Wednesday 8 July that “cases like this are always concerning”.
“My department has only just received the Coroner’s recommendations and will consider them carefully.”
He said such issues would be considered as the State Government developed its 10-year mental health strategic plan.
On Monday 6 July, Mr Olle found the victim had died from multiple injuries and immersion in a home swimming pool in Narre Warren on 25 January 2009.
The perpetrator – whose name was omitted in Mr Olle’s report – had an “alcohol dependence disorder” and killed the victim during a mutual weekend drinking session.
He had been released as an involuntary patient from Casey Hospital on 16 January after taking his parents hostage in a seven-hour siege two weeks earlier.
Mr Olle’s inquest focused on the killer’s medical management, but he emphasised his role was not to lay blame.
In his report, Mr Olle referred to the man making threats to kill beforehand, his frightened parents intending to take out intervention orders, and his instability and intimidation in the ward.
Two days before the fatal assault, a case manager interviewed the man and judged him to be threatening in manner but not a risk of harm to others, Mr Olle said.
“(His) hallucinations and delusions were still present and real to him.”
Mr Olle said the care by Monash Health staff was “not unreasonable or inappropriate” in the circumstances but “hindsight has revealed poor clinical decisions were made”.

Digital Editions


  • Cracking start to the year

    Cracking start to the year

    **There are different ways of breaking a cricket bat. TOORADIN star Cal O’Hare has done it twice the conventional way; basically being too good for…

More News

  • Young players stars chase American dream

    Young players stars chase American dream

    A group of local young basketball players is set to take their skills international, with a life-changing educational trip to the United States planned for April 2026. The Pakenham Basketball…

  • Derby delivers pure magic

    Derby delivers pure magic

    Purchase this photo from Pic Store: 531164 WOMENS PINK V WHITE DERBY If you’re ever trying to explain why local baseball is so good, you could simply point to Saturday…

  • Lions happy and hammered

    Lions happy and hammered

    PAKENHAM BOWLS Pakenham’s Weekend Pennant teams returned a very mixed bag on Saturday. Pakenham One (Div 1) was always in control of its home game against Beaumaris One, despite a…

  • Parents Change of Preference Advice

    Parents Change of Preference Advice

    Missed their ATAR? A parent’s guide to VTAC Change of Preference The end of Year 12 brings a whole array of mixed feelings for you as a parent. You’re excited…

  • Yannathan local and Melbourne Royal President earns OAM

    Yannathan local and Melbourne Royal President earns OAM

    Purchase this photo from Pic Store: 530162 Yannathan local Matthew Coleman has received a fair few calls from Canberra in his lifetime, but he had never received one from Government…