PAKENHAM OFFICER STAR NEWS
Home » Overly offended

Overly offended

I read Owen Carlton’s letter mocking Mr Rudd for his light aside when he called himself a “Kokoda survivor” after completing the modern day walk of that historic track.
Owen, I admire you as an ex-serviceman and respect what you and the others all did for Australia. This is no slight on you.
I just want to say that I reckon you have read too much into Mr Rudd’s comments.
I can’t agree with you that his comments shows that “he believes himself to be the most important person who has ever experienced it”.
He was referring to the modern trek, not the original war time experience!
His comments were at worst flippant and insensitive, but they were not some kind of utter arrogance and self absorbed delusion.
He does not “disrespect 104,000 Australians who made the ultimate sacrifice” (as you said). You jump to an extreme conclusion that reflects more your political bias than the actual incident.
You also criticised his apology “if I have offended anyone…”.
It seems to me that that phrase is common public usage for apologies.
Did you get upset with Alan Jones when he gave a similar (actually much weaker) apology after saying what he did about Ms Gillard’s father, for example?
Did you write a letter condemning him?
Jim Reiher,
Eumemmerring.

Digital Editions


  • Emerald recognised as haven of the arts

    Emerald recognised as haven of the arts

    Emerald is a haven for the arts, and that passion has been given well-deserved recognition at Cardinia’s Australia Day awards. The Emerald Arts Society won…

More News

  • Mother takes torch, named Senior Citizen of the Year

    Mother takes torch, named Senior Citizen of the Year

    A lifetime of quiet compassion has been brought into the spotlight, with longtime volunteer Maureen Timms named 2026 Senior Citizen of the Year at the Cardinia Shire Australia Day Awards.…

  • Kids charged over alleged thieving spree

    Kids charged over alleged thieving spree

    Three boys from Greater Dandenong are facing charges over an alleged stealing spree across the South East. The trio were arrested by police on Princes Highway, Noble Park on Wednesday…

  • A testimony of hope

    A testimony of hope

    Purchase this photo from Pic Store: 448546 Rose’s family escaped South Sudan’s civil war and settled in Ethiopia for safety in refugee camps. In 2000, when she was 6 years…

  • Rising star shines

    Rising star shines

    Some talents shine brightest when given room to grow and Soumil Aggarwal is proof. From a simple school project, he’s crafted a film that’s capturing attention across Victoria. Gazette journalist…

  • Backhands, burns and banks

    Backhands, burns and banks

    DAVE: Morning boys, an absolute scorcher on the weekend and one member of our team is sporting the war-wounds of sunburn to prove it. We praised Blair last week for…